pnpm (Performant npm) is a popular package manager renowned for its efficient storage and speed. However, despite its numerous advantages, pnpm has some drawbacks. The main points are as follows:
-
Compatibility Issues: Although pnpm strives for compatibility with npm, complex projects may encounter issues due to differences in dependency handling. pnpm optimizes storage space and installation speed by utilizing soft links and a unique
node_modulesstructure, which can sometimes lead to incompatibility with tools or scripts relying on specific file structures. -
Community and Ecosystem Support: While pnpm's user base is growing, its community and ecosystem remain less mature and extensive compared to npm or Yarn. This means that for certain specific issues or edge cases, ready-made solutions or external plugin support may not be readily available.
-
Learning Curve: For new users, unique concepts introduced by pnpm (such as the soft-linked
node_modulesstructure) may require some learning and adaptation. Although these features provide performance benefits, they can initially confuse new users. -
Migration Costs: For projects already using npm or Yarn, switching to pnpm may involve migration costs. Although pnpm provides tools and commands to simplify the process, large or complex projects may encounter issues requiring time and resources to resolve.
-
Performance in Certain Environments: Based on user feedback, pnpm performs well in most cases but may fall short of expectations in specific systems or configurations. This could relate to how pnpm handles file links and caching across different file systems or operating systems.
In summary, although pnpm offers appealing features like efficient space utilization and speed, it still has drawbacks to consider. For teams or individuals evaluating pnpm, understanding these potential issues and assessing their impact on your specific scenario is important.